Improv Challenge: Peanut Butter & Jelly Heart Cookies


Peanut butter and jelly. What in the world other than a sandwich am I supposed to make with that? That was my first thought after reading the Improv Challenge ingredients for April. Usually I'm all for thinking outside of the box and trying to create something that no one else will have thought of.

But then I found these cookies. They were just so cute that I decided to hell with the creative recipes, I want to make these! So that's just what I did.

Let's back up a second. If you're a new follower/reader you may not know what the Improv Challenge is. The short and sweet of it is that Kristen, over at Frugal Antics of a Harried Homemaker, created this little challenge where each month there are two ingredients and you can make whatever you want as long as they are included. Obvious, unusual, savory, sweet, strange...whatever you desire. Then, on the third Thursday of each month, we all post and share our creations. Sound interesting? If you want to join, just click HERE for more information.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Heart Cookies
Source: Delish via Martha Stewart Living
Yield: approx. 3 dozen cookies
Printer Friendly 

    • 1 stick unsalted butter, at room temperature
    • 1/2 cup sugar
    • 1/2 cup brown sugar, packed
    • 1 1/2 cups all purpose flour
    • 1 1/2 tsp. baking powder
    • 1/4 tsp. salt
    • 1 egg
    • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
    • 1/2 cup jam/jelly/preserves flavor of your choice (I used strawberry)
1. In the bowl of your stand mixer with the beater attachment, cream together the butter with both sugars.
2. In a bowl, combine the flour, baking powder and salt.
3. Add the peanut butter and egg to the butter/sugar mixture and mix until combined. Slowly add in the flour until fully combined.
4. Refrigerate the dough for 10-20 minutes or until its easy to handle.
5. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper.
6. Scoop about two tablespoons of the dough and roll into a ball. Flatten slightly into the palms of your hands and place on the baking sheet. Repeat with remaining dough, placing about 2 inches apart.
7. Use your fingertips to press a heart shape into each piece. Refrigerate for 20 minutes.
8. Preheat the oven to 350. In a small bowl, stir the jam/jelly/preserves of your choice to loosen it.
9. Spoon the jam/jelly/preserves into the heart shape of each cookie. Bake for 16-18 minutes, checking on the cookies around 12 minutes to ensure they don't burn.
10. Let cool to room temperature on a wire rack then place in a container and refrigerate until ready to eat.

The original recipe calls for baking the cookies for 12 minutes then adding the jam/jelly/preserves and baking for an additional 5-6 minutes. I did this on my first batch and my hearts puffed up kinda funny after the first 12 minutes of baking. After adding the jam/jelly/preserves, they didn't look so pretty. I had intended to just keep going that way and hope I got some cookies pretty enough to photograph out of the deal, but it was late, I was tired and I accidentally added the jam to a batch before cooking them. They turned out much prettier than the other batch so I did that for the remaining dozen of cookies.

I'm not a huge peanut butter cookie fan but the jam/jelly/preserves is a nice aspect to these cookies and they're also not overwhelmingly peanut butter flavored. Plus, aren't they just adorable with the hearts? :-)


  1. Those are so pretty! Love the hearts. Oh, and the peanut butter! :)

  2. Yes, these are adorable!!! Love them!!

  3. Love the hearts. I love how bright the red is.

  4. At first I thought they were cutout cookies, how clever! I will definitely be trying these on my PB&J loving family.

  5. These are adorable, and they look very tasty! A wonderful recipe!

  6. What a great idea for these classic ingredients. They are so pretty and I bet delicious, too! : )

  7. Delicious AND pretty! I'll take 3 please, with a cup of coffee! If you have someone knocking on your door with an empty coffee mug and a puppy dog look on their face - it's me! Just feed me cookies and send me on my way!

  8. Really pretty and I'm sure delish. Will have to remember these for Valentine's Day next year!

  9. I love peanut butter cookies! That jelly heart in the middle is adorable and I bet it was delicious :)

  10. These cookies look really good! I really like the jelly heart!

  11. they look beautiful and they would make a perfect gift!

  12. Yumm! These cookies wouldn't stand a chance in my house - I'm a sucker for pb cookies!


AdChoice Icon, to be placed in the footer:

Total Pageviews

Back to Top